Editorial Notice We may earn an affiliate commission when you purchase through links on our site. Read our full disclosure.

WELLNESSCOMPARED Independent Supplement Research
Trust & Transparency

Editorial Policy & Scientific Review Standards

Our core promise: Uncompromising scientific integrity, zero vendor kickbacks in scoring, and transparent nutraceutical analysis.

Published: January 15, 2026 β€’ Last Audited: October 2026 β€’ Senior Editor: Rachel Adams, MS

1. The 5-Stage Scientific Audit Process

Every dietary supplement, nootropic, metabolic enhancer, and wellness formulation reviewed on WellnessCompared undergoes a standardized 5-stage evaluation protocol before receiving an editorial rating:

01

Ingredient Verification

Cross-referencing the Supplement Facts label against botanical indexes, verifying full chemical forms and active alkaloid percentages.

02

Clinical Dosage Benchmarking

Comparing declared milligram dosages directly against double-blind, placebo-controlled trials published on PubMed (NIH) and ScienceDirect.

03

Manufacturing & Quality Audit

Checking for current Good Manufacturing Practice (cGMP) certifications, NSF/USP verification, and FDA registered domestic facility standards.

04

Pricing & Guarantee Verification

Auditing refund timelines (30, 60, or 180 days), recurring billing traps, auto-ship disclosures, and multi-country shipping rates.

2. Zero Paid Placements & Editorial Independence

We strictly prohibit paid editorial reviews or guaranteed positive scores. Neither ClickBank, BuyGoods, nor independent brand owners can buy a higher ranking or alter our pros, cons, or bottom-line verdict.

While we participate in affiliate partnerships to fund our research operations, our editorial team operates completely independently of commercial arrangements. If a product underdoses key active ingredients or utilizes deceptive proprietary blends, we say so unequivocally.

3. Medical Fact-Checking & Research Citations

All nutritional and botanical assertions must link to authoritative, peer-reviewed biomedical literature. We prioritize:

  • PubMed / National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI): Human randomized clinical trials (RCTs).
  • World Health Organization (WHO) & NIH Office of Dietary Supplements: Recommended Dietary Allowances (RDA) and upper safe limits.
  • US Food & Drug Administration (FDA): Safety advisories and recall notices.

4. Corrections & Update Cadence

Supplement formulas evolve frequently. When a brand modifies its ingredient ratio, rebrands, or adjusts its pricing structure, our team updates the review within 5 business days.

If you identify a factual error, price mismatch, or discontinued SKU in any of our articles, please submit a correction to our editorial desk at our contact page. All verified corrections are amended immediately with a clear update timestamp.

Editorial Review Board

All articles are curated and reviewed under the direction of licensed nutritionist researchers and fitness specialists.